g_dipoles does not work properly with ionic systems
g_dipoles tries to compensate for charged molecules by subtracting the net charge of each molecule. In (small) periodic systems the dipole is not well defined since it may change rather abruptly if one ion moves to another image.
#1 Updated by Erik Lindahl almost 5 years ago
- Tracker changed from Bug to Feature
David - any suggestions what should be done? If we think of a charge distribution in terms of expansions, I think the dipole should indeed be the first moment around the net charge, so then the subtraction seems correct?
Similarly, as far as I can tell the small system issue is a a problem with system size and PBC, not a problem with how g_dipoles calculates dipoles. It's not obvious to me that it is a problem that can be fixed, and even if it is, that sounds more like a feature. Feel free to change back to "bug" when there is a description of something that can be fixed!