Task #3188
Task #2792: Improvement of PME gather and spread CUDA kernels
re-enalble parallel spline calculation for #threads/atoms > 4
Description
The recent changes to the spread/gather kernels removed the parallel spline calculation (formerly enabled with PME_GPU_PARALLEL_SPLINE macro) which would allow utilizing 3x4=12 (instead of 4) of the 16 threads instead letting most of them idle.
This should improve performance for small input sizes where the 16 threads/atom kernel is already faster (hence it will also be important for an efficient pipelined spread and PME decomposition); preliminary data based on the 2019 code-base supports this.
Associated revisions
History
#1 Updated by Szilárd Páll 3 months ago
- Subject changed from re-implement paralle spline calculation for #thrads/atoms > 4 to re-enalble paralle spline calculation for #thrads/atoms > 4
#2 Updated by Szilárd Páll 3 months ago
- Subject changed from re-enalble paralle spline calculation for #thrads/atoms > 4 to re-enalble paralle spline calculation for #threads/atoms > 4
#3 Updated by Jonathan Vincent 3 months ago
- Subject changed from re-enalble paralle spline calculation for #threads/atoms > 4 to re-enalble parallel spline calculation for #threads/atoms > 4
I had a better look at what PME_PARALLEL_SPLINE does and it does 3 things.
Uses 12 threads instead of 3 for the final dtheta calculation (i.e. just for calculating the final difference)
Uses 12 threads instead of 3 for writing the theta values to global memory
uses shared memory instead of an array for the theta values.
Implemented this at https://gerrit.gromacs.org/c/gromacs/+/14077
For 16 threads with save and reload by far the largest effect was the shared memory change at large sizes.
I also then tried the shared memory change for 4 threads and recalculation and it had limited effect.
#4 Updated by Paul Bauer about 1 month ago
- Status changed from New to Resolved
I think this is resolved now?
#5 Updated by Paul Bauer about 1 month ago
- Status changed from Resolved to Closed
Update PME CUDA spread/gather
Adds addtional templated kernels to the CUDA spread and
gather kernels. Allowing the use of 4 threads per atom instead of
16 and allowing the spline data to be recalculated in the spread
instead of saved to global memory and reloaded.
The combinations mean we have 4 different kernels that can be called
depending on which is most appropriate for the problem size and
hardware (to be decided heuritically). By default existing method is
used (16 threads per atom, saving and reloading of spline data).
Added an additional option to disable the preloading of charges and
coordinates into shared memory, and instead each thread would
deal with a single atom.
Removed the (currently disabled) PME_GPU_PARALLEL_SPLINE=1 code
path.
Refs #2792 #3185 #3186 #3187 #3188
Change-Id: Ia48d8eb63e38d0d23eefd755dcc228ff9b66d3e6